Why should Isis and Hamas have all the fun blowing up stadiums and shooting up concert-goers? I also want to have some fun. I also want to give back to my oppressors. I want to maim people that ignore me. I want to run over women in my wheelchair that don’t give me the time of day. Then when I get arrested, I can say that I’ve been humiliated and ignored all my life. 58 years, how much can one man take? I had to express my rage. Would that be acceptable? Would that be legitimate?
My point is that any behavior can be legitimized. Now what about Isis? What about Hamas? What about Al Quaeda? What about Hitler? They all have reasons for being angry, even Hitler. Germany was completely humiliated at Versailles. They were sidled with huge debts that completely crippled the economy. Hamas wants their land back. Isis is repulsed by the spread of our materialistic, profane western culture. They want to have their own caliphate to protect their values.
And the west does the same thing. We legitimize our killings. For example, when the US killed hundreds of thousands of civilians in Iraq, we justified it by saying it was to get rid of Saddam Hussein and his supposed weapons of mass destruction. It’s just that we in the west have the media to legitimize any war we undertake.l
Of course, the more power or money you have on your side, you can always bombard people and give your justification the feeling of complete absoluteness. Like they say, the victors write the history. The mouthpieces of the victors are BBC, CNN, and The New York Times. We are brainwashed; we never question it. In fact, we are so brainwashed that we never even see it as justification. We just accept it as gospel.
But beyond justification, is violence ever right? Gandhi said no. Martin Luther King said no. Malcolm X said yes. God says yes if they’re Canaanites occupying the promised land. It’s one of the most difficult questions that us humans face. But, if there’s ever going to be a clear answer, let us at least see it as a question.
Okay, I have to go, I have to run over a Jew-for-Jesus that wants to invite me for Shabbos lunch. But before I do, let me take my own advice. Do I really have a right to hurt another human being? As of this second, I have to answer with a resounding no. But come talk to me the next time you see me in the Shuk.